Jump to content

Which is the best Standalone Firewall?


KotaXor

Recommended Posts

have spent more than 8 hours on the comp after installing comodo and used each and every software on the comp and WOW hardly a dozen popups

i can hardly believe this, comodo is going to remain on my comp for a long long time - it is much superior than zonelarm or any other firewall

Link to comment
Share on other sites


  • Replies 134
  • Views 41.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Glad you liked this release - I was beginning to regret having made the Commodo post.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Don't make me regret using ZoneAlarmPro, hahaha....

Now trying latest Comodo on another PC....if all goes well.........well we see

Nothing is wrong with ZoneAlarm though!!! decision decision!!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Comodo has as much pop-up as ZoneAlarm Pro...only ZoneAlarm free does not have much pop-up.

Then again, pop-up is to warn you on certain program being modify, ie if you know which is which (whether it is geniune or malware).

Link to comment
Share on other sites


  • 2 weeks later...

I actually only like comodo without defense +, I don't want a nagging HIPS firewall.

My router already has a firewall and I think that in combination with nod32 is enough for me.

I don't do anything dangerous, and if I do, I do it in a virtual environment.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Most of the time i have to fix friends and families computers is because of the fact that they DO NOT use their firewall and anti virus programs properly. When i sit back and watch over their shoulders and tell them to do what they normally do on the internet...i always see them just clicking "yes" or "OK" when firewall pop ups come on screen...Meaning they never read the damn window to see what they just agreed to be installed or allow to happen on a web site no anti virus and fire wall combination can protect a user if the user does NOT use "their first line on defense...that is the brain they have in their heads"...that last quote is paraphrasing the big leader called "Lite"...

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Most of the time i have to fix friends and families computers is because of the fact that they DO NOT use their firewall and anti virus programs properly. When i sit back and watch over their shoulders and tell them to do what they normally do on the internet...i always see them just clicking "yes" or "OK" when firewall pop ups come on screen...Meaning they never read the damn window to see what they just agreed to be installed or allow to happen on a web site no anti virus and fire wall combination can protect a user if the user does NOT use "their first line on defense...that is the brain they have in their heads"...that last quote is paraphrasing the big leader called "Lite"...

Agreed with you, let them stay with Windows Firewall then rather than just clicking "Yes". Most ppl do not read the pop-up, or just does not understand what is being prompt as sometime it can be quite confusing to what the pop-up is trying to said.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


lal krishna

I like Zonealarm Pro,because it tells you about each and every thing.But it is a resource hog in low end PCs.I didn't like Eset/KIS09 firewalls,because it never tells you.tOO LEAKY(Believe me,I have been thru settings).

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Yes very true, ZoneAlarm Pro is a very user-friendly and likable firewall - the latest version has improved comparatively and hogs lower CPU cycles as compared to previous versions. Earlier ones were also painful at bootups/startups.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


good to hear zonealarm is lower on the cpu... comodo is good... :frusty:

Link to comment
Share on other sites


good to hear zonealarm is lower on the cpu... comodo is good... :think:

Presently, I am still using ZoneAlarm. Its good.

Till something else come along.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


comodo rocks and all my friends now use it

we instaled comodo on 11 machines and hardly any popup in 10 machines but on 1 machines we saw many popups. somebody please help. thankful in advance

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Please try the following:-

1. Uninstall the Comodo program

2. Remove all traces of leftover folders & files

3. Re-install afresh (just confirm that your friend has the latest version)

4. Use default settings during installation (they can always be customized, later)

5. Do not neglect to install Defense+ (it's possible to disable it later if you dislike it but not vice versa)

6. Towards the end of the installation allow the setup to scan for malwares when prompted to

ps: One can always quieten the Defense+ and Firewall further by configuring them independently as follows:-

1. Defense+ Go to Defense+ -----> Advanced -----> Defence+ Settings -----> General Settings. You may slide the Defence+ Security Level down to Training Mode

1. Firewall Go to Firewall Behaviour Settings -----> Advanced -----> Firewall Settings -----> General Settings. You may slide the Firewall Security Level down to Training Mode.

(Important Warning From einstürzende: The Training Mode should be resorted to only temporarily like for example while playing a offline game - this Mode can compromise your system and make it vulnerable.)

BTW, I prefer to leave my Defense+ and Firewall Security Level at the default Safe Mode - the only pop-ups I ever have is during an installation of any new software (this is countered by the improved Installation Mode which is somewhat like the Game Mode in ZoneAlarm Pro.) With the above tips you'll find that Comodo outperforms ZoneAlarm Pro or any other firewall, for that matter.)

Link to comment
Share on other sites


May I add, once you upgrade the version of comodo all your past settings will be re-set.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Please try the following:-

1. Uninstall the Comodo program

2. Remove all traces of leftover folders & files

3. Re-install afresh (just confirm that your friend has the latest version)

4. Use default settings during installation (they can always be customized, later)

5. Do not neglect to install Defense+ (it's possible to disable it later if you dislike it but not vice versa)

6. Towards the end of the installation allow the setup to scan for malwares when prompted to

ps: One can always quieten the Defense+ and Firewall further by configuring them independently as follows:-

1. Defense+ Go to Defense+ -----> Advanced -----> Defence+ Settings -----> General Settings. You may slide the Defence+ Security Level down to Training Mode

1. Firewall Go to Firewall Behaviour Settings -----> Advanced -----> Firewall Settings -----> General Settings. You may slide the Firewall Security Level down to Training Mode.

BTW, I prefer to leave my Defense+ and Firewall Security Level at the default Safe Mode - the only pop-ups I ever have is during an installation of any new software (this is countered by the improved Installation Mode which is somewhat like the Game Mode in ZoneAlarm Pro.) With the above tips you'll find that Comodo outperforms ZoneAlarm Pro or any other firewall, for that matter.)

ok writing this down now to try at my friends place

Link to comment
Share on other sites


einstürzende

Quick warning for training mode (please read all reds)

From CFP3 help, D+ department:

"Training Mode: The firewall will monitor and learn the activity of any and all executables and create automatic 'Allow' rules until the security level is adjusted. You will not receive any Defense+ alerts in 'Training Mode'. If you choose the 'Training Mode' setting, we advise that you are 100% sure that all applications and executables installed on your computer are safe to run.

Tip: This mode can be used as the “Gaming Mode”. It is handy to use this setting temporarily when you are running an (unknown but trusted) application or Games for the first time. This will suppress all Defense+ alerts while the firewall learns the components of the application that need to run on your machine and automatically create 'Allow' rules for them. Afterwards, you can switch back to 'Safe Mode' mode)."

From CFP3 help, FW department:

"Training Mode : The firewall will monitor network traffic and create automatic allow rules for all new applications until the security level is adjusted. You will not receive any alerts in 'Training Mode' mode. If you choose the 'Training Mode' setting, we advise that you are 100% sure that all applications installed on your computer are assigned the correct network access rights.

Tip: Use this setting temporarily while playing an online game for the first time. This will suppress all alerts while the firewall learns the components of the game that need internet access and automatically create 'allow' rules for them. Afterwards you can switch back to your previous mode."

Link to comment
Share on other sites


. . . . . thanks for the info. - it makes sense and does add up. :rolleyes:

(my post # 116 has been updated with your above quotes.)

Link to comment
Share on other sites


According to the latest Matousec tests, the new Agnitum Outpost Firewall Pro 2009 is the best! Check it out: http://www.matousec.com/projects/firewall-...nge/results.php.

I guess it all boil down to how you let it access, you if click OK or Allow every time you are prompt, then the best firewall is still useless.

So what's your point?

His point is that every firewall, how perfect or not, needs to be guided by a knowing person. If you just randomly click an answer in every box when it asks you for an answer then any firewall is nearly useless.

Even the best firewall configured by an idiot will give you worse protection than the worst firewall configured by an expert.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...