Jump to content

FBI & DEA Warn That IPv6 May Be Too Damn Anonymous


Adrean

Recommended Posts

IPv6 has been around for quite some time at this point, but as we get closer and closer to moving the internet over to the system, it appears that American and Canadian law enforcement has just noticed that it's not as easy to identify and track users, and they're frantically raising concerns.

FBI, Drug Enforcement Administration, and Royal Canadian Mounted Police officials have told industry representatives that IPv6 traceability is necessary to identify people suspected of crimes. The FBI has even suggested that a new law may be necessary if the private sector doesn't do enough voluntarily.

The issue has more to do with record-keeping than technology. As Declan McCullagh explains at the link above:

ARIN and the other regional registries maintain public Whois databases for IP addresses, meaning that if you type in 64.30.224.118, you can see that it's registered to CNET's publisher. ARIN tries to ensure that Internet providers keep their segments of the Whois database updated, and because it's been handing out IPv4 addresses blocks every few months, it currently enjoys enough leverage to insist on it.

But for IPv6, ARIN will be handing out much larger Internet address blocks only every 10 to 15 years, meaning it loses much of its ability to convince Internet providers to keep their Whois entries up-to-date. That means it may take law enforcement agencies -- presumably armed with court orders -- longer to trace an IPv6 address such as 2001:4860:4860::8888 back to an Internet service provider's customer.

Of course, some might see that as a feature, not a bug. Either way, I would imagine that most service providers will bend over backwards to make sure that law enforcement can, in fact, track people down if necessary. Too many service providers fold when the feds come knocking seeking information on people already. As long as this is presented as a way to protect children or stop terrorists or whatever the favorite of the day is, it seems likely that ISPs will get things in order themselves.

:view:Original Article: TechDirt

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 3
  • Views 1.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Either they don't really like IPv6 because of said reasons OR, they actually DO like it for opposite reasons and this is just their way of playing possum; pretending to be against it so that we can only naturally push for it.

The United States Federal Reserve system was setup in a similar way too. The big bankers were saying "No, Please don't create a central banking system!!!", when all they wanted was just that! It's the equivalent of finding a rabbit eating your front yard lawn and you snatch him up and assuming he could talk he says, "Oh please don't ever throw me in your garden! I hate it there!" and so you do just what he says he hates when in reality, he LOVES the garden.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Either they don't really like IPv6 because of said reasons OR, they actually DO like it for opposite reasons and this is just their way of playing possum; pretending to be against it so that we can only naturally push for it.

The United States Federal Reserve system was setup in a similar way too. The big bankers were saying "No, Please don't create a central banking system!!!", when all they wanted was just that! It's the equivalent of finding a rabbit eating your front yard lawn and you snatch him up and assuming he could talk he says, "Oh please don't ever throw me in your garden! I hate it there!" and so you do just what he says he hates when in reality, he LOVES the garden.

The old fashioned art of the Double Bluff.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Either they don't really like IPv6 because of said reasons OR, they actually DO like it for opposite reasons and this is just their way of playing possum; pretending to be against it so that we can only naturally push for it.

The United States Federal Reserve system was setup in a similar way too. The big bankers were saying "No, Please don't create a central banking system!!!", when all they wanted was just that! It's the equivalent of finding a rabbit eating your front yard lawn and you snatch him up and assuming he could talk he says, "Oh please don't ever throw me in your garden! I hate it there!" and so you do just what he says he hates when in reality, he LOVES the garden.

and we're being too anxious about their motives...what's what
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...